Search a question on Google and there's often an AI answer at the top, before any websites. So is your website still worth paying for? Yes, but its job has changed. Here's what the data shows and what to do about it.
Is my website still worth it if Google answers first?
Yes. Google's AI Overviews mostly answer questions; they rarely replace the search a customer makes when they're ready to book. Your website still does the job that matters most: turning someone who's ready into a call or an enquiry.
What has changed is the traffic from questions. In a study of 68,879 real Google searches, Pew Research Center found people clicked a normal result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, against 15% when it didn't. They clicked a link inside the summary in just 1%.
Which searches do AI Overviews take, and which do they leave?
It depends on how people search. In Pew's study, AI summaries appeared on 18% of searches overall, but the type of search made a big difference:
| Type of search | Example | AI summary shown |
|---|---|---|
| One or two words | plumber Box Hill | 8% of searches |
| Starts with a question word | how much does a blocked drain cost | 60% of searches |
| Ten words or more | why does my hot water run out so fast in winter | 53% of searches |
Short service-and-place searches are usually made by people ready to hire, and they mostly still show normal results. In our own Search Console data, two in five non-brand searches that showed soudcoh.com named a place. Question searches are where clicks are falling.
Your website now has two jobs
- Turn the visitors who do arrive into calls and forms. Fewer clicks means each one matters more. A clear phone number, a short form and a page for each service help; here's a website that turns visits into calls and forms.
- Be the source the AI reads and quotes. When Google, ChatGPT or Claude answers a question, it pulls from pages that answer it clearly. Plain answers near the top of a page, specific facts and up-to-date details make yours a better source. That's what AI search optimisation focuses on, and it starts with whether Claude and other AI assistants can read your site.
AI Overviews take the questions. Customers ready to book still search, click and call.
Should I move my budget to Google Ads instead?
Not instead, but alongside. Ads put you in front of people searching right now, which suits urgent jobs and new services. Organic search and AI answers build more slowly but keep working when you stop paying. Good Google Ads management uses the search terms that bring real enquiries to decide which pages to build next, so the two help each other.
What to do this month
- Split your Search Console queries. Put service-and-suburb searches in one group and questions in another. Watch clicks for the first group and impressions for the second.
- Strengthen your service pages. One page per main service and area, with prices or how pricing works, and the areas you cover.
- Answer questions directly. Put a one- or two-sentence answer straight under each question heading, then the detail.
- Track calls and forms. If fewer people click but more of them enquire, your website is doing its job.
- Check AI tools monthly. Ask the same questions each month and track how often AI tools mention you.
How SoudCoh helps
We build service pages that win the ready-to-hire searches, rewrite question pages so AI tools can quote them, and track the calls and forms that come from both. If you're looking for the best marketing agency for your business, start with a free marketing audit and we'll show you which of your searches AI Overviews are taking and which still send customers.
Common questions about AI Overviews and your website
Do AI Overviews cite small business websites?
They can. Pew found Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit were the most cited sources overall, so a small business competes by having the clearest, most specific page on its own services and area.
Can I stop my website appearing in AI Overviews?
Google says its usual snippet controls, such as nosnippet, also apply to its AI features. Using them can make your normal search listing less useful too, so most businesses are better off making their pages worth citing.
Is SEO still worth paying for?
For most service businesses, yes. The searches that bring paying customers, like a service and a suburb, mostly still show normal results. What changes is that question pages need to be built to be quoted, not just clicked.
Questions and answers
Do AI Overviews show for searches like 'plumber near me'?
Less often. In Pew's study, AI summaries appeared on only 8% of one- or two-word searches, against 60% of searches that started with a question word.
How much do AI Overviews reduce clicks?
Pew found people clicked a normal search result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, compared with 15% when it didn't.

